The workers... battle-cry must be: 'The Permanent Revolution.'” — Marx and Engels, 1850

Sex and the Revolution meeting report

"The government forced me to work on the street," says Manchester sex worker

Members of the Marxist Radical Forum, including myself, were hugely excited at the turn out of our first ever meeting, “Sex and the Revolution”. 60 people attended with two speakers from the English Collective of Prostitutes and one from the International Union of Sex Workers, alongside myself, Vicky from the Marxist Radical Forum. I spoke first. I commenced with an anecdote about the Christmas present I received at my second Christmas… A vacuum cleaner! From there, I spent fifteen minutes giving a potted history of sex, sexuality and gender, as well as the Marxist response to the questions of women’s and LGBTQ liberation, and finally, prostitution.

The second speaker, Cari from the English Collective of Prostitutes, talked about the difficulty experienced by sex workers attempting to get jobs outside of the sex industry, especially after being convicted for sexual offenses. She refuted Harriet Harman’s claims that the majority of prostitutes want criminalization of their clients and referred to the “moralistic crusade” that some feminists and Socialists embark on whenever the subject of prostitution turns up. She also talked about the many debt-ridden students who turn to sex work to fund their studies.

The third speaker, also from the English Collective of Prostitutes, had a heartbreaking story. A widow, she was a prostitute simply to support her severely disabled son. It was a way of earning money. With a previous conviction for prostitution, she found it next to impossible get another job that would enable her to support her son without putting him into care. In her words, ‘the government forced me to work on the street’. The problem with society is not prostitution, she said... It’s poverty.

The final speaker, Catherine from the IUSW, talked about the sheer numbers of sex workers in the UK, estimating that there are 80,000 women who have sold sexual services in this country. According to Catherine, wherever there is a crackdown on “kerb crawling”, there is a rise in attacks on prostitutes, as vulnerable women spend less time deciding whether or not to get into cars. She talked about the violence prostitutes often experience, not necessarily from their clients, but from the local community, and the targeting of brothels by violent gangs. However, Catherine was a woman who enjoyed her job and the freedom she felt it gave her. On the whole, her experience of the sex industry had been a positive one.

All of the speakers mentioned one thing: the importance of decriminalization as the only way to drastically improve the lives of prostitutes. And stemming from that, the need for self-organisation and strength through unity. Feminists and Socialists who didn't listen to the voices of prostitute women were condemned by all and the lively debate following the speakers was largely positive.

The next meeting of the Marxist Radical Forum, “World On Fire”, will be held in MR4 of Manchester University’s Students’ Union on the 13th October. For more information on us, check out our blog. We encourage all Manchester Marxists to contact us and get involved.

 

Tue 30, September 2008 @ 20:26

Bookmark with:

What are these?

discussion of this article

bill j said…

This was a really excellent and very promising start, with an overwhelmingly woman audience, great speakers and a vibrant discussion. Well done all.

Tue 30, September 2008 @ 20:34

Wladek Flakin said…

Congratulations that you were able to transform PR's fascinating and original work about prostitution into a successful meeting!

Tue 30, September 2008 @ 22:08

Tina said…

The meeting sounds excellent. Getting 60 young people, mainly women, to a meeting to discuss the nature of sex work and to listen to the experiences of sex workers, demonstrates that young women are not passive consumers of the gender roles that society imposes on them. Young women today, like their sisters before them, clearly want to grapple with the big questions that they are faced with regarding sexuality and how to fight for a more liberated vision of sexual relations.

There is clearly an audience out there for a Marxist response to these questions. Well done all. I do wish I could have been there.

Wed 01, October 2008 @ 10:57

Helen said…

This sounds like a great meeting - I wish i could have been there but I had to work. The advance of "moralistic-feminism" is frightening, with its attempts to outlaw sex work as simply a form of violence against women. Harriet Harman is typical of this approach and the government is trying to further criminalise clients by suggesting this helps women. In fact, as you report, this is likely to make things more dangerous for sex workers and goes against the notion of decriminalising sex work. The government are obsessed with "cracking down" on any behaviours they disagree with, and uses scare stories about trafficked women and children as a cover for raids on brothels and deportations of sex workers. Of course there are trafficked women and children, although they are a minority in the sex industry, but that is an inevitable result of racist, reactionary immigration controls together with poverty and inequality. If the sex industrty was decriminalised, workers would better able to organise in unions, and to collectively fight against the extreme exploitation that affects many workers. While it remains hidden and outside the law then evertyone in it is muchmore vulnerable.

See more about this at www.permanentrevolution.net/entry/1556

Anyone wanting to get involved in action against government attacks on sex workers should keep in touch with one or more of:

International Union of Sex Workers www.iusw.org

Safety First Coalition www.allwomencount.net

Feminist Fightback www.feministfightback.org.uk

Wed 01, October 2008 @ 13:04

Chris S said…

Brilliant meeting, good to see so many people interested and involved. Look out for future actions in Manchester before the end of the year =D

Wed 01, October 2008 @ 15:01

Jason said…

Yes excellent meeting would have been there myself but for an urgent and sudden meeting that i couldn't really get out of. Excellent start to the MDF and sounds like a really good meeting.

Wed 01, October 2008 @ 17:18

add to the discussion

   

your details (optional)

name
e-mail address
URL

Your e-mail address will not be shared.

your comment

Separate paragraphs with blank lines; HTML markup will be removed; URLs will be converted to links.